The Herald Banner, Greenville, TX

Top News

July 31, 2013

Appeals court hears arguments in fight over pipeline

GREENVILLE — A state appeals court heard arguments in Greenville Tuesday over a Lamar County woman’s fight against the installation of an oil pipeline on her land.

For her part, Julia Trigg Crawford felt the hearing before the Sixth District Court of Appeals could not have gone better.

“I thought that it went incredibly well,” Crawford said of her attempt to overturn an August 2012 ruling in the case of The Crawford Family Farm Partnership v. TransCanada Keystone Pipeline, L. P.

The decision in the Lamar County Court at Law upheld TransCanada’s condemnation of a 50-foot strip of land across Crawford’s pasture. The pipeline is being built to carry oil to Texas refineries from Canada.

Wendi Hammond, Crawford’s appeal attorney, argued TransCanada wasn’t eligible to receive a summary judgment in its favor in the case, as it does not meet the definition of a “common carrier” under the Texas Natural Resource Code.

Hammond claimed TransCanada does meet the definition of a general common carrier, but not a common carrier with eminent domain authority, which is reserved for companies which transport materials “intrastate”, or inside the state.

“It is bringing oil from outside the State of Texas into the State of Texas,” Hammond said, denying that decisions in similar cases set a precedent in the current appeal. “This is a new case.”

TransCanada attorney James Freeman said the distinction between intrastate and interstate business does not exist under the law regarding a common carrier and, even so, the proposed pipeline clearly meets the standard of a common carrier with eminent domain authority under the Texas Business Organizations Code, as it will meet the “public use” requirement.

“This is a pipeline that is going to bring tens of thousands of jobs to Texas,” Freeman said. “Jobs do go to the public use.”

The appeals court did not immediately issue a ruling in the case.

Crawford was impressed by the justices, whom she said appeared interested in the arguments and were “aggressively sympathetic to the arguments from both sides.”

She expects an additional appeal, to the Texas Supreme Court, to take place no matter how the court rules. Crawford believes TransCanada would automatically appeal if the appeals court rules in her favor and she intends to do the same if the decision goes against her.

“I have nothing to lose and the longer we stay in this the more the truth comes out,” Crawford said.

1
Text Only
Top News
  • Band1.jpg Roaring with pride

    The Greenville High School Lion Pride Band performs well under pressure, according to GHS band director Joel Weisburg

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Royce Tawater.jpg Shooting suspect changes mind on guilty pleas

    On second thought, a local man will leave it up to a jury to decide whether he is guilty of multiple charges in connection with two shootings in Greenville last summer.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Easter Eggstravaganza stork photo.jpg A hunting we will go

    There will be lots of brightly colored eggs hidden in the grasses across Hunt County this weekend, and plenty of opportunities for children to find them.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • GEUS Operations Center.jpg Saying thanks to police

    The board of the local electric utility system intends to take time tonight to thank officers with the Greenville Police Department for catching suspects who allegedly broke into the company’s headquarters last month.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Field.jpg GISD trustees approve replacing track, turf

    When the Greenville High School football team takes the field in August, they will be marching out onto new turf.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Royce Tawater.jpg Guilty pleas expected in July 2013 shootings

    A  Greenville man, sentenced to state prison earlier this year on a weapons charge, is scheduled to plead guilty today to multiple counts involving two different shootings in July 2013.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • GPD stock photo.jpg Guilty plea given in child injury case

    A local woman has pleaded guilty to seriously injuring a child in Greenville in February of last year.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Jefferies.jpg Bond issue questions asked, answered

    If the proposed $72.275 million Greenville Independent School District bond passes, the district will move from the third-lowest school district tax rate in Hunt County to sixth out of 11 school districts in tax rates.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Start of mall project getting closer

    Something new has been added to the property on which rests Crossroads Mall in Greenville, but it is not another store or restaurant.

    April 15, 2014

  • Painting_With_a_Twist_feature_(1).1.jpg "it gets easier and easier'

    Diagnosed with terminal cancer, with only about a month left to live, Quinlan resident Mike Loftin needed a spiritual lift, something fun and entertaining to keep his mind off of his illness.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

House Ads
Featured Ads
Poll

What's your favorite spring high school sport?

Swimming and diving
Wrestling
Basketball
Soccer
Tennis
Golf
Track and Field
Softball
Baseball
     View Results
Facebook
AP Video
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Real Estate News